Fake it till you make it is terrible advice. That's the argument Brian Demcher is making in this episode of She Sells He Sells — and he's got a billion-dollar case study to back it up.
In the relaunch episode of She Sells He Sells: Ideas Worth Buying, Brian makes a bold pitch: the phrase "fake it till you make it" isn't just overrated career advice — it's a mindset that quietly chips away at your integrity, your reputation, and your results. And Krista Demcher? She's not buying it. At least not at first.
Brian traces the idea back to one of the most infamous business collapses in recent history: Theranos. Founded in 2003 by Elizabeth Holmes, the company raised $1.3 billion across 11 funding rounds on a premise her own professor told her was scientifically impossible. Holmes modeled her appearance, her voice, even her wardrobe after Steve Jobs — performing the part of a visionary while knowingly building on a lie. She ended up in federal prison.
Is that the extreme end? Sure. But Brian argues that fake it till you make it sets a dangerous precedent for how we think about confidence, career growth, and personal integrity — especially for people just starting out who are already battling self-doubt and imposter syndrome.
The alternative? Lean into your why, not your lie. That means building real confidence through hard work, purpose, and authenticity — not performing a version of yourself you haven't earned yet. Brian walks through why integrity, honesty, and a clear sense of purpose are the actual foundations of a sustainable career, and why Franklin Covey's four pillars of credibility (integrity, purpose, capabilities, results) don't leave any room for the word "fake."
Krista brings the debate. She makes the case that not everything fake is bad — lab-grown diamonds, anyone? — and pushes back on whether Brian is taking a simple mantra way too seriously. Their conversation covers reputation management in the modern career landscape, the unrealistic timelines fake it till you make it sets for people, and what it actually looks like when someone builds a career on honesty and work ethic instead of performance.
By the end, both hosts agree on more than they expect. But the verdict on the phrase itself? That's up to you.
This is Episode 200 of She Sells He Sells — the first episode of the rebrand — and it kicks off with the debate that's been living in the Demcher household for years. Tune in next week for Episode 201, where Krista argues the other side.
IN THIS EPISODE
[0:00] Intro: Krista explains the 5 S's framework and previews what Brian is selling today — and where to listen for the good stuff
[2:10] Welcome back to the rebrand — Brian states his sell and Krista tells him immediately she's not buying it
[3:37] The Story begins: a startup founded in Palo Alto in 2003 raises $1.3 billion across 11 funding rounds and 300+ investors. Then it all falls apart. The Theranos and Elizabeth Holmes story.
[8:22] Krista pushes back: is this actually fake it till you make it, or is it fraud — and does it matter?
[9:57] The Solution: integrity, honesty, purpose, and passion — and the phrase Brian came up with: "Lean into your why, not your lie."
[12:24] The debate gets interesting: Krista makes the case that fake isn't always bad. Lab-grown diamonds, a #1 Dad trophy, and a hypothetical fake Rolex walk into the argument.
[16:51] The Stakes: your reputation is everything in the modern professional world — and fake it till you make it chips away at the one thing you can't buy back
[21:17] What success actually looks like: a strong sense of self, less pressure, and a reminder from the smartest person Brian knows — "real beats perfect every single time"
[25:43] The close: do you buy it? Cast your vote.
KEY QUOTE
"Lean into your why, not your lie."
MENTIONED IN THIS EPISODE
Theranos and Elizabeth Holmes
Franklin Covey's Four Pillars of Credibility: integrity, purpose, capabilities, results
"Real beats perfect every single time" — Krista Demcher
DON'T MISS EPISODE 201
Krista flips it. Same topic, completely different verdict. You'll want both sides before you vote.
____
Connect with us:
📸 Instagram: @SheSellsHeSellsPodcast
▶️ YouTube: She Sells He Sells Podcast
Apr 13 202637 Min.
48 Min.