• Faith, Truth, and Accountability: A Conversation with Bill Hambleton
    Nov 9 2026
    Content note: This episode includes discussion of clergy sexual abuse, institutional responses to abuse, trauma, and the death of a loved one by suicide.What does it mean to love the Church while asking it to face the harm done within it?Author and Catholic educator Bill Hambleton joins The Catholic Leadership Puzzle for a candid conversation about faith, broken trust, and the responsibility of Catholic leaders to care for the people entrusted to them. Drawing on his memoir, The Sacred and Profane: A Memoir of Faith and Reckoning, Bill shares how abuse by a priest during his youth affected his discernment, his ability to trust, and his relationship with the institutional Church—while his faith continued to sustain him.The conversation explores Bill’s account of reporting the abuse decades later, his concerns about the response he received, and his hope for meaningful reform. Together, we examine servant leadership, the difference between protecting people and protecting institutions, and the courage required to listen without becoming defensive.Bill also reflects on his brother Matthew’s death, the prayer practices that continue to ground him, and the hope he finds in his family and students. For clergy, parish staff, ministry leaders, and lay Catholics, this episode offers a searching invitation: listen to those who have been wounded, welcome accountability, and let the care of people shape how we lead.Key discussion points· Faith and institutional trust are distinct. Bill describes how his faith endured even as his trust in Church leadership was profoundly damaged.· Disclosure can require decades of courage. His story underscores how much a survivor may have overcome before approaching a Church representative.· The response to abuse matters deeply. Bill explains why the defensiveness and lack of transparency he says he encountered compounded the original harm.· Reform requires a change in culture. He calls for the Church’s commitments to survivor care and accountability to become lived practice.· Authentic Catholic leadership is service. The conversation draws on Lumen gentium, the Good Shepherd, and Pope Francis’s image of shepherds who remain close to their people.· Listening and love for the Church can coexist. Taking a survivor’s experience seriously does not require abandoning one’s faith or defending every institutional action.· Prayer sustains hope and action. Bill describes contemplative silence, family life, and teaching as continuing sources of strength.Chapters00:00 Introduction to Bill Hambleton and The Sacred and Profane01:05 Catholic upbringing, seminary formation, and the impact of abuse04:31 Why tell the story? Faith, broken trust, and hope for reform08:05 Shepherding, institutional priorities, and the Dallas Charter10:25 Beyond policy: the need for a change in Church culture12:56 Mission, accompaniment, and accountable leadership15:44 Servant leadership, Lumen gentium, and clericalism18:15 Bill’s account of the investigation and barriers to transparency21:26 Experiences of pastoral care and the importance of good shepherds23:54 Hope, grief, and finding the courage to disclose abuse27:49 Listening honestly: a concrete invitation for Catholics31:32 Prayer, contemplation, and the people who sustain hope35:20 Where to find the book and learn more36:11 Closing challenge: care for people and hold leaders accountableResources· The Sacred and Profane: A Memoir of Faith and Reckoning — official book website. Bill shares this address near the end of the interview; the site includes a purchase link and information about the memoir.· USCCB: Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People, revised June 2026. The document discussed as the Dallas Charter. Bill offers his assessment of its revisions and their limitations.· Second Vatican Council: Lumen gentium. Bill reflects on studying this document in Rome and the tension between its vision of the Church and his own experience.· Pope Francis: Chrism Mass homily, March 28, 2013. Original source for the image of shepherds with the smell of their sheep, recalled during the conversation.· The Salt Lake Tribune: reporting on Bill Hambleton’s account. Bill mentions the newspaper’s coverage near the end of the interview without naming a specific article. This verified story concerns his account; access may require a subscription. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thecatholicleadershippuzzle.com/subscribe
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    38 min
  • The Sacred and Profane: Faith, Trust, and Accountable Leadership with Bill Hambleton
    Nov 9 2026
    **Content note: This episode discusses clergy sexual abuse, institutional betrayal, trauma, and the death of a family member by suicide.What does faithful Catholic leadership look like when trust has been broken? Christina Semmens welcomes Catholic educator and author Bill Hambleton for an honest conversation about his memoir, The Sacred and Profane: A Memoir of Faith and Reckoning, and his hope for a Church that more fully lives its mission of care.Bill recounts the abuse he experienced as a teenager, its effect on his discernment of priesthood and capacity to trust, and his eventual decision to report it. He describes both the institutional responses he found deeply hurtful and the pastoral relationships that offered support. Throughout the conversation, he distinguishes his enduring faith in God from his damaged trust in Church leadership.Together, Christina and Bill explore servant leadership, transparency, accountability, and the difference between written commitments and a culture that puts people first. They discuss the Dallas Charter, the vision of the Church expressed in Lumen Gentium, and the importance of hearing survivors without immediately defending the institution. Bill also shares how contemplative prayer, family life, and teaching young people continue to sustain his hope—and his desire for meaningful reform.This is a CLP conversation is challenging, but is a vitally important one as we strive to create communities that save souls, make saints and transform the world. Key Takeaways- Faith and institutional trust are distinct. Bill describes how his faith has sustained him even as his experiences have profoundly damaged his trust in Church leadership.- Reform requires a change in culture. Policies and inspiring language need to be reflected in everyday decisions, pastoral care, and the treatment of people who bring concerns forward.- Servant leadership makes room for accountability. Christina and Bill challenge leaders to place the people entrusted to them at the center of their service and to accept honest questions about their actions.- The response to a disclosure matters deeply. Bill explains how the response he encountered after reporting abuse became another source of hurt. His account underscores the courage it can take for someone to speak.- Listen before defending. Allowing a survivor to be heard and acknowledging harm can coexist with love for the Church and commitment to its mission.- Transparency must be practiced. Bill raises questions about what independence and accountability mean when an institution controls an investigation and access to its findings.- Hope does not require silence about wrongdoing. Bill’s desire for reform grows from his faith and his concern for the next generation.- Prayer and relationships can sustain a life of service. Bill finds hope in contemplative silence, his marriage and daughter, and the young people he teaches.Suggested ResolutionsTry to apply one of these in your life in the week ahead:1. Practice listening without an immediate defense. In a difficult conversation, give the other person space to finish. Acknowledge what they have shared before offering an explanation or response.2. Ask an accountability question. With your parish or ministry team, discuss: Can people raise concerns here and expect to be heard? What would demonstrate that we take their concerns seriously?3. Close one gap between words and actions. Choose one commitment your ministry makes about care, welcome, or service. Identify a concrete action that would make that commitment more visible.4. Make time for quiet prayer. Spend five minutes in silence with God. Bring both your love for the Church and any grief or frustration you carry into that prayer.5. Lead where you have been entrusted to serve. Reflect on Christina’s closing questions: Am I caring for my people? Am I accountable? Am I asking the same of my leaders? Choose one next step.Chapters00:00 — Welcome: Bill Hambleton and The Sacred and Profane01:02 — Faith, seminary, abuse, and the loss of trust04:50 — Why Bill told his story—and his hope for reform08:25 — The Dallas Charter and questions about reform10:25 — Moving from written promises to a culture of care13:23 — Shepherding, authority, and accountable leadership15:40 — Servant leadership and the vision of Lumen Gentium18:06 — Bill’s experience of investigation and transparency23:50 — Hope, grief, and the courage to speak27:53 — A concrete invitation: listen without defending31:24 — Contemplative prayer, family, and sources of hope35:14 — Find the book and connect with Bill’s story36:12 — The baptismal call to care, truth, and accountabilityResources The Sacred and Profane: A Memoir of Faith and Reckoning — official website for purchasing information, endorsements, press coverage, and events.Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People — USCCB, revised June 2026 — Often called the Dallas Charter. This is ...
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    38 min
  • A Clear Path to Everyday Evangelization with Jim Jansen
    Oct 20 2026
    How can a busy parish move from a calendar full of activities to a shared mission of making disciples? That is the question that Christina Semmens and Jim Jansen focus upon in the midst of an extremely practical conversation about relationships, clarity, and teamwork that all are necessary to make parish renewal possible.Jim Jansen is the author of the book, A Clear Path, in it, he explains four essential parts of a discipleship pathway: relational outreach, conversion moments, faith formation, and equipping people for mission. In this conversation, Jim and Christina explore why parishes often stall between helping people grow in faith and preparing them to share it—and how simple, personal mentoring can bridge that gap.The conversation also addresses rebuilding trust between dioceses and parishes, recognizing complementary gifts, sharing responsibility with the pastor, and discerning when a longstanding ministry has run its course. Jim also shares what the process of growing fruit has taught him about work, rest, patience, and trusting God with the harvest. The conversation closes with encouragement to prepare parish communities to welcome, accompany, and integrate people who are seeking Christ.Key Takeaways- A shared mission gives parish activity direction. Knowing why a ministry exists—and how it contributes to making disciples—helps leaders collaborate and reduces competing demands on parishioners.- Renewal begins with relationships. Diocesan and parish leaders build trust by showing up, listening, learning people’s circumstances, and offering practical help.- A clear path includes four connected elements. Help people connect with the community, encounter Jesus and respond to him, grow in discipleship, and become equipped for their own mission.- Formation needs to lead to mission. Learning about the faith matters, but parishioners also need help sharing it with friends, family, neighbors, and coworkers.- Mentoring can be simple: tell, show, try, do. Explain a skill and its purpose, model it, provide supported practice, and help someone grow able to do it themselves.- Strong teams bring complementary gifts. A shared vision, trust, and personal maturity allow people with different strengths to serve together. One leader cannot supply every gift.- Discern both growth and pruning. Ask Jesus what a ministry needs now. Sometimes the faithful next step is to grow a small, fruitful initiative; sometimes it is to give tired volunteers permission to stop.- Make room for the next leader. Teaching others and communicating a planned transition can open space for people who would otherwise hesitate to step forward.- Respect the seasons. Fruitfulness requires timely work, rest, and trust. Jim’s orchard offers a reminder that spiritual growth cannot be rushed.Chapters00:00 — Welcome: Jim Jansen and the work of parish renewal03:49 — A shared “why” and a clear direction for evangelization07:28 — Building trust between diocesan leaders and parishes10:24 — Knowing your people and connecting parish ministries14:17 — The four parts of a discipleship pathway19:41 — Connecting the call to holiness with the call to mission22:22 — Practical mentorship: tell, show, try, do25:06 — Patient evangelization and the strength of working together28:58 — Shared responsibility, trust, and complementary gifts33:55 — When a longstanding ministry needs to change or end38:10 — Fatigue, delegation, and making room for new leaders41:37 — What an orchard teaches about work, rest, and trust44:26 — Signs of hope for the Church and missionary renewal48:33 — Preparing to welcome and accompany people seeking Christ49:44 — Connect with Jim and explore his resourcesResourcesConnect with JimEveryday Evangelization — Jim’s main website with access to his book, podcast, consulting work, and conversation-booking options.A Clear Path: How to Make Missionary Disciples in Your Parish — Jim’s bookThe EquipCast — Jim’s podcast, Anchor Consulting — Jim’s consulting work Alpha for Catholics ChristLife FORMED Gallup CliftonStrengths Working Genius — The Table GroupMyers-Briggs Type Indicator Suggested Resolutions1. Map your parish’s pathway. Identify where people connect, encounter Jesus, grow as disciples, and become equipped for mission. Choose one gap to bring to prayer and discussion with your leadership team.2. Listen across ministry boundaries. Meet with one fellow ministry leader to learn whom they serve, what they need, and how your efforts could support one another.3. Mentor one person in one skill. Use “tell, show, try, do” to help someone practice a small act of leadership or sharing faith.4. Discern your current season. Ask the Lord whether you are being invited to persevere, teach someone else, make room for a successor, or let an activity come to a peaceful close. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit...
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    51 min
  • SPP Book Resources and Mark Your Calendars!
    May 10 2026

    In this video, Christina discusses the story behind the Solving the Parish Puzzle book, and the resources available to help unpack and implement the principles within your ministry and community.

    During the video, she speaks of the SPP Inventory and also the SPP Vision Board Exercise, both free resources available on The Catholic Leadership Puzzle website.

    She also announced the upcoming Zoom Q&A session happening on Wednesday, June 3rd at 7pm CST. The session will be focused upon answering any questions that YOU want answered from your reading the book, so you are invited to send any questions to christinasemmens@gmail.com

    As a thank you for anyone who submits a question, they will be sent a copy of the SPP Book discussion questions, which currently are available only for Catholic Leadership Puzzle paying subscribers.

    The Catholic Leadership Puzzle is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.



    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thecatholicleadershippuzzle.com/subscribe
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    17 min
  • Solving the Parish Puzzle is now available as an Audiobook on Audible!
    Oct 7 2026
    Wonderful news! After several months of work, my latest book, Solving the Parish Puzzle, One Person, One Disciple, and One Leader at a Time, is now available as an audiobook on Audible!Just like the book itself, the audiobook allows me to personally guide you through the concepts of the book, and share why so many parish renewal efforts are falling short despite good intentions, dedicated leaders and numerous programs. Solving the Parish Puzzle, One Person, One Disciple, and One Leader at a Time presents a clear, practical, and deeply Catholic framework to help you build healthy, mission-driven parish communities that are focused on saving souls, making saints, and transforming the world.From more than three and a half decades of ministry experience, leadership formation, and evangelization practice, I outlined the twelve essential practices, or puzzle pieces that each parish needs to be attentive and seek to have in place within the community. I also tried to move beyond theory by giving a repeatable, relational, and prayer rooted approach to leadership and discipleship that all work together to not only create a community of communities that we’re longing for. But it’s not just create to create one, but to sustain it in a community where people are known by name, accompanied with care, and empowered to live out their baptismal call to the fullest. This book is written for anybody, but especially if you’re serving as a ministry leader, on parish staff, or ordained clergy. Bottom line, if you are trying to renew a parish community, this book is for you. So I hope that you’ll go and check it the Solving the Parish Puzzle audiobook.Finally, feel free to reach out to me if you got questions or if you would like for me to come work with your team. You can sign up at my website for a free consultation on the link at christinasemmens.com. That consultation would just be a conversation where we can sit, talk, and determine how I might be able to help you. I hope to connect with you soon. In the interim, I hope you enjoy the audiobook version of Solving the Parish Puzzle: One Person, One Disciple, One Leader at a Time. The Catholic Leadership Puzzle is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thecatholicleadershippuzzle.com/subscribe
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    5 min
  • Pope Leo XIV and Pastoral Initiatives
    Sep 26 2026

    This has been a glorious week in the life of the Church—the addition of a new American Blessed—Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen—and Pope Leo XIV’s visit to France. Both of those momentous occasions might have overshadowed an absolutely brilliant address that Pope Leo gave to the Diocese of Rome at Saint John Lateran Basilica to mark the beginning of the new pastoral year.

    The city of Rome and its people is actually the primary responsibility for Pope Leo to shepherd. He also is responsible for shepherding the worldwide universal Church—and this responsibility is what we usually associate with the Pope, but he is first and foremost, bishop of Rome, and this address was directed primarily at those within the Rome diocese, however, what Pope Leo tells them are words that all of us need to hear and respond.

    In fact, when I read this address, I actually joked that Pope Leo must have read my book, Solving the Parish Puzzle, because the ideas are so similar! But the reality is that the Pope’s address actually reaffirms that the book I wrote truly is of the Holy Spirit because they are a reflection of what the Holy Father is asking us to be attentive within our parishes.

    The work I do within The Catholic Leadership Puzzle—of writing, speaking, giving retreats and coming alongside pastors, leadership teams, and ministry groups in assisting them in implementing the ideas found within my book are all with the hope that by being attentive to the work of the Holy Spirit, we may save souls, make saints, and transform the world.

    If you would like to learn more about how I might be able to help you and your ministry do what Pope Leo speaks about, then reach out and let’s talk!



    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thecatholicleadershippuzzle.com/subscribe
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    16 min
  • The Power of Hospitality: Insights from Richard McCorry
    Aug 1 2026

    Discover how fostering authentic hospitality can transform your Catholic community. Join us as Richard McCorry shares his journey, the spiritual foundation of welcoming, and practical steps for parishes to become more inclusive and life-giving, especially remembering that welcoming the stranger is not optional.

    Key Topics

    * Richard McCorry’s faith journey and calling to promote hospitality

    * The biblical and spiritual foundations of welcoming strangers

    * Common misconceptions about hospitality in parishes

    * The importance of culture change over quick programs

    * A step-by-step process for creating a culture of welcome

    * Leadership’s role in fostering hospitality

    * Practical first steps for parishioners to encourage welcoming environments

    * The significance of assessing parish reality from a stranger’s perspective

    * How true hospitality supports evangelization and community growth

    * Real-life examples of hospitable parishes and their impact

    Timestamps:

    00:00 - Introduction to Richard McCorry and the importance of hospitality00:45 - Richard’s faith journey and calling to serve through hospitality01:49 - The biblical basis for welcoming strangers02:46 - Why hospitality is central to Catholic life and evangelization03:21 - Challenges and misconceptions in parish hospitality04:34 - History and inspiration behind McCorry’s book, Companies Coming05:30 - The spiritual importance of welcoming the newly merged parishioners06:48 - How being truly hospitable impacts visitors and newcomers07:49 - Hospitality as a culture, not just a program or committee08:46 - The process of developing welcoming parishes09:45 - The importance of understanding the “why” behind hospitality efforts10:20 - Misconceptions about hospitality and the depth of the spiritual practice11:21 - Hospitality as a whole-parish responsibility12:30 - Moving beyond quick programs to sustainable culture change13:58 - The process of assessing, discerning, planning, and implementing welcoming initiatives15:11 - Practical steps for parishioners to engage in hospitality16:40 - Overcoming resistance and examining parish realities honestly18:28 - Connecting hospitality with evangelization, drawing from the parable of the sower19:50 - Addressing the needs of both newcomers and long-time parishioners22:17 - The vital role of parish leadership and pastors25:35 - Practical first steps for parishioners to promote welcoming environments26:30 - The importance of seeing through a stranger’s eyes and the impact on church attendance28:15 - Recognizing and nurturing the faith of existing parishioners29:40 - Leadership as a model for cultivating hospitality in the community30:19 - McCorry’s final encouragement to prioritize culture over quick fixes35:21 - How to connect with Richard and access his resources for parishes

    Resources & Links:

    * Catholic Hospitality

    * Company’s Coming: A Spiritual Process for Creating More Welcoming Parishes

    * Richard McCorry on LinkedIn

    Connect with Richard McCorry:

    * Website

    * LinkedIn

    * Twitter



    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thecatholicleadershippuzzle.com/subscribe
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    38 min
  • Christian Leadership Insights with Shawn Sommerkamp
    Jul 17 2026
    In this episode of The Catholic Leadership Puzzle Podcast, Christina Semmens sits down with Shawn Sommerkamp, Executive Leadership Coach and founder of Motivationeer Christian Coaching. His focus is to help leaders grow in their profession without compromising their faith in Christ. In this discussion, Christina and Shawn explore how Christian leadership, discipleship, and emotional health can be lived out in ordinary work, and how faith-based leadership can transform organizations as well as your own personal growth. Executive Leadership Coach Shawn Sommerkamp shares practical insights on integrating Christian principles into leadership, managing success spiritually, and fostering a healthy emotional and spiritual life.In this episode, you’ll learn about:* How to view your workplace as your full-time ministry* The importance of integrating discipleship and leadership* Traits and habits of Christian leaders making a kingdom impact* The difference between corporate and church leadership mistakes* Strategies for maintaining spiritual vitality and emotional health* The significance of setting and trusting in God-led goals* Practical rhythms for daily spiritual leadership and self-care* How to discover and align with your divine purpose in everyday work* Common leadership myths and the importance of investing in high-potential talent* Why leadership and discipleship should be integrated* The difference between ethical leadership and Christian leadership* How humility and self-denial shape kingdom-minded leaders* Why churches and businesses drift from their mission* The role of prayer in discerning God’s purpose* How to identify and live from your core values* Why emotional health matters in spiritual leadership* Daily rhythms that help leaders stay spiritually grounded* Practical leadership myths, habits, and priorities to rethinkKey Takeaways* Christian leadership is not separate from discipleship — it’s part of it.* Humility means lifting others up, not diminishing yourself.* Mission drift often comes from greed, pride, or losing sight of God’s calling.* Prayer and discernment help us stay faithful to today.* Knowing your core values can reveal why work relationships and environments create conflict.* Emotional detachment and healthy boundaries are essential in spiritual work.* Sustainable leadership depends on rest, rhythm, and wise investment of time.Memorable Moments* Shawn on his calling: discovering that his workplace was his full-time ministry* A discussion of the “fruit of the Spirit” as a model for leadership* The danger of success becoming spiritually distracting* Why churches can learn from business about strategy and measurable goals* Shawn’s practical advice: go to bed at the same time, wake up at the same time, and start the day with protein and prayer* Rapid-fire leadership wisdom, including the importance of investing in rising talentQuotes* “My workplace is my full-time ministry.”* “The most important thing is I’m His.”* “What is it you want me to do today?”* “We’re not self-degrading. We’re just lifting them up.”* “The biggest leadership myth is that you gotta work eighty hours a week to be the best.”Timestamps 00:00 - Introduction to Sean Sommerkamp and his ministry journey01:12 - The role of workplace as full-time ministry in faith-based leadership02:09 - Integrating discipleship and leadership as God’s calling03:45 - Traits of impactful Christian leaders: humility and self-denial04:58 - The importance of humility modeled by Jesus and John the Baptist05:41 - How success can become spiritually dangerous when misaligned with God’s mission06:26 - Handling church leadership transitions without feeling threatened07:52 - Celebrating growth and success in church and corporate settings11:28 - The role of strategy and teamwork in both church and business growth12:35 - Why organizations drift from their mission and how to protect it13:28 - The dangers of greed and materialism undermining spiritual and organizational health15:45 - How to discover God’s purpose through prayer and daily obedience16:52 - The importance of recognizing and respecting core values22:07 - Balancing spiritual leadership with emotional health and well-being26:44 - Practical rhythms for maintaining spiritual vitality: sleep and nutrition28:36 - Leadership habits and myths: from breathwork to work-life balance29:12 - A daily habit every Christian leader should adopt: prayer on knees30:20 - The importance of investing in rising talent and leadership development31:17 - Connecting further with Shawn Sommerkamp via his websiteResources and Links* Willpower Doesn’t Work by Benjamin Hardy* Motivation Ear* Motivation Ear on YouTubeConnect with Shawn Sommerkamp* Motivationeer Leadership Coaching* LinkedIn* TwitterMay this episode inspire you to lead with faith, humility, and purpose every day.The Catholic Leadership Puzzle is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and ...
    Visa mer Visa mindre
    32 min