Shut up, Heather! The newest episode of the Greatest Show Pod is out now! This time, Brandtly and Emily cover the Off-Broadway cult classic, Heathers: The Musical. Is it Big Fun, or will it make you want to Freeze Your Brain? (Also, Happy Musical Reveal Week to all who celebrate! We hope you find the hints for the 2026 Spring show!)

This episode was recorded on October 4, 2025.

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show!

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube

Hold on to your loin cloths, because this week we are swinging on vines and yelling about Tarzan! Emily and Brandtly discuss the fascinating choices that were made when this musical was produced for Broadway. Will this show be in our hearts? Or is it just to Different for us to love? #justicefortantor

This episode was recorded on August 9, 2025.

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show!

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube

The greatest tragedy in American history... or just the greatest tragedy to befall Broadway? Join us this week as Brandtly and Emily discuss this Frank Wildhorn flop. Should I Tell My Father about this show, or will it Never Pass This Way Again? Listen now!

This episode was recorded on July 30, 2025.

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show!

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube

Are you ready for our close up? Look at Sunset Boulevard, Andrew Lloyd Webber's best(?) musical. Will Brandtly and Emily fall in love With One Look? Or will they wish they said goodbye a long time ago?

This episode was recorded on July 27, 2025.

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show!

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube

Happy Season 3! We're back with the granddaddy of all mega-musicals, Les Miserables! Join us as we critique this show and answer the age old question: are nineteenth century French men deserving of love? (Friendly reminder that Cameron Mackintosh probably scammed some old ladies for this.)

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Please leave us a rating and review if you're enjoying the show!

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube

SO FETCH! Please come sit with us for the end of Season 2 as we discuss the Mean Girls stage musical!

Content warning: Emily didn't bleep the language as it pertains to lyrics of songs. (If you don't like that, maybe skip this one.) Everything else is censored as usual.

This episode was recorded on November 26, 2024. (Yeah, yeah, it was supposed to come out in January. We've been busy. Sorry.)

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube

We'll be back for Season 3 later this year! See you then!

Oh baby, baby, have we got a show for you. This week, Emily and Brandtly are back to spill some tea about Britney...s music and its use in this "Crazy" musical, Once Upon a One More Time. Is it "Toxic" or were they screaming "Gimme More?" Either way, you can be sure that it is one hell of a "Circus!”

Content warning: Emily didn't bleep the language as it pertains to titles of songs. (Mostly Work B*tch. If you don't like that, maybe skip this one.) Everything else is censored as usual.

This episode was recorded on August 2, 2024. Rest in peace to our favorite, Gavin Creel. We would've loved to see you as Prince Charming.

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays from all (ahem, both) of us at It's the Greatest Show, Man! Our Christmas special is a little late, but we hope you still have some holiday spirit and will join us for our discussion of Journey to Bethlehem. Grab some hot cocoa, pull up Netflix, and enjoy some time away from your family! This episode was recorded on November 25th, 2024.

Follow us on social media! @greatestshowpod

Patrick Duffy, Music Extraordinaire:

• patrickduffymusic.com
• Instagram
• YouTube