Amish woman, Evelyn King, had spent years being disappointed in her husband and her marriage. When Evelyn's husband died, leaving her pregnant and with a three-year-old daughter, she is faced with many problems including a house in ill-repair. When the quiet and kind Hezekiah Hostetler suddenly proposes, Evelyn knows this will solve all her problems as Hezekiah is nothing like her late husband. While pondering on his proposal, a handsome new man visits the community and offers to fix her house. Can Evelyn put the bitter memories of her past marriage and challenges behind her? Or will her fear of abandonment cause her to jump into another unsuitable marriage?