In this episode, Winston tackles a common and important question: Why be Catholic? Exploring the Christian desire for unity and objective truth, the episode centers on one key idea - apostolicity. Winston explains how the Catholic Church today is the same Church founded by Jesus on the apostles, preserving the same mission, teachings, and authority for over 2,000 years.

Through the lens of apostolic authority, truth, and unity, the episode shows how the Catholic Church provides a living teaching authority, safeguarded by the Holy Spirit, that maintains doctrinal truth and visible unity among believers. Drawing from Scripture and early Church history, Winston argues that this apostolic foundation leads to the fullness of Christianity - offering the sacraments, unity with Christ, and a deeper intimacy with Him.

Whether you’re Catholic, Protestant, or simply curious, this episode invites you to consider how authority, truth, and unity fit into Christ’s plan for His Church - and why apostolicity matters.

In this episode, Winston tackles the big question: Is the Catholic Church infallible? Building on the previous episode (“When Did the Catholic Church Begin?”), he breaks down what “infallible” really means—both in general and in the context of Church teaching. Winston explains how the Church’s claim to infallibility applies only to official teachings on faith and morals, not to every word spoken by popes or bishops.

He dives into the biblical foundations for this belief, exploring Jesus’ words to Peter (“whatever you bind on earth…”) and the promise of the Holy Spirit guiding the Church “into all truth.” Winston also unpacks the relationship between Scripture and the Church—how the Church, through divine guidance, discerned which writings belong in the Bible—and addresses the common objection that the Catholic claim to infallibility is “circular reasoning.”

Ultimately, he shows that both Protestants and Catholics rely on faith in God’s guidance, but that the Catholic understanding best fits the historical and biblical evidence of Christ establishing a Church protected from error.

In this episode, Winston explores the question: When did the Catholic Church begin? Tracing history backward from today’s thousands of denominations to the earliest centuries of Christianity, he explains the Catholic claim that the Church founded by Jesus on Peter in 33 AD is the same Church that exists today. Drawing from Scripture, the structure of the early Church, the role of bishops and apostolic succession, and the unanimous beliefs of the first Christians, Winston shows how the Catholic Church has remained unbroken through history.