Are you struggling with fear of failure in sports, performance anxiety, or playing scared in competition? Many athletes believe they lack confidence, but the real problem is often fear of mistakes, fear of embarrassment, and fear of letting others down. When fear controls your game, confidence cannot show up — no matter how skilled you are.
In this episode, mental performance coach Eli Straw explains why working through fear is more important than building confidence. Confidence is trust in your ability, but if fear of failure is present, athletes hesitate, second-guess, and underperform — especially under pressure.
This episode is for athletes who:
• Perform well in practice but struggle in games
• Feel confident in training but tight or hesitant in competition
• Deal with performance anxiety or fear of mistakes
• Struggle with confidence, pressure, or overthinking
• Feel like they are holding themselves back
What You’ll Learn
• Why fear of failure in sports blocks confidence and causes timid play
• The connection between performance anxiety and playing scared
• Why confidence alone does not prevent choking under pressure
• How fear leads to hesitation, overthinking, and underperforming in games
• A simple 3-step mental training process to reduce fear and play freely
• How to trust your skills and compete with confidence under pressure
Eli shares real examples from a professional basketball player and a Division 1 baseball player who overcame fear of mistakes, competitive anxiety, and self-doubt to perform freely and aggressively in competition.
The Key Mental Game Truth: Confidence does not eliminate fear. Fear must be addressed first.
When athletes reduce fear of failure, their natural confidence, trust, and ability begin to show — allowing them to stop playing scared and start competing freely.
Work With Eli Straw
Eli Straw is a mental performance coach who helps athletes overcome fear of failure, performance anxiety, negative self-talk, and confidence struggles through a structured mental training system. Athletes learn how to build trust, play freely, and perform under pressure.
➡️ Interested in 1-1 mental performance coaching? Schedule your free introductory call to learn more: https://www.successstartswithin.com/get-coaching
🥇Team Mental Performance Coaching Program: https://www.successstartswithin.com/mental-coaching-for-teams/
👉 Confident Competitor Academy: Go from playing with fear & anxiety to playing with confidence in just 6 weeks!
👉 Mentally Tough Kid Course
📖 Mind Games Book: https://a.co/d/gXZfORN
📖 Athlete Mental Training Book: https://a.co/d/bfojamY
Free Training: Top 5 Mental Mistakes Athletes Make
*This podcast is for educational purposes only and does not constitute psychological or medical treatment. I am a mental performance coach, not a licensed psychologist. For clinical concerns, consult a licensed professional.