Skylar Neese’s murder shocked the nation not only because of its brutality, but because it was committed by people she trusted most. Her case led to changes in West Virginia’s missing-children alert procedures now referred to as Skylar’s Law. Skylar didn’t run away. She was taken by the friends who promised to protect her.

Colleen Slemmer was brutally murdered in 1995 after being lured into the woods by people she trusted. The killing was fueled by jealousy and a teenage love triangle, ending in a savage beating and stabbing. The case made history when one of her killers, Christa Pike, became the first woman set for execution in Tennessee in over 200 years, marking a grim and controversial milestone in capital punishment.

Join us to discuss the new Netflix documentary, "This is the Zodiac Speaking."

In the quiet area near Rough River, Kentucky, a brutal and bizarre crime shattered the sense of safety locals thought they had. This episode dives into the disturbing case of George Greer, known as the “Samurai Sword Killer,” whose violent attack left a community searching for answers. We unravel who Greer was, what led up to that night, and how a weapon straight out of legend became part of a very real nightmare. This is a story of sudden violence, unanswered questions, and a town forever changed.

We decided to do a BONUS "palette cleanse" Book Talk for fun! Everyone needs a break from true crime, even true crime podcasters! Listen and we discuss The River is Waiting by Wally Lamb. This book wasn't really the cleanse we were expecting, but more of a book that had us questioning morality and how we really thought we knew where we stood on difficult subjects such as addiction, prison, and forgiveness. WARNING: THIS IS A SPOILER! We do tell the ending, so don't listen until you have read the book if you plan on reading. This is a story we will never forget and will forever struggle with expressing our feelings on these events.

This story is crazy to me! How did one person’s drawing turn into something that quickly became known throughout many states across the country? This is the story about some crimes related to this Slenderman picture.

Matthew Winkler was a respected minister, a devoted father, and the face of a seemingly perfect life—until his wife, Mary Winkler, shot him while he slept. What followed shocked their small Tennessee community and sparked a national debate about abuse, faith, and what really happens behind closed doors. In this episode, we unravel the events leading up to Matthew Winkler’s death, the secrets of their marriage, and the controversial trial that divided a nation.

In the early morning hours of November 16, 2012 a family in a quiet Ohio suburb would forever be changed. Lisa Knoefel, a social worker and foster mother was brutally killed in her home. She was stabbed over 150 times while she was in bed. The attack was carried out by 17 year old Sabrina Zunich, the Knoefel’s foster daughter. Listen and let us know what you think. Is Sabrina a cold blooded killer, or was she manipulated by someone she should have been able to trust?