In this chilling episode, Ally and Jonathan revisit the tragic and perplexing death of JonBenét Ramsey. A little girl’s life, stolen under the Christmas lights, left behind only questions and heartbreak. Nearly three decades later, the pain still echoes louder than the answers.

This week, Ally dives into a case that rocked the headlines and left an island paradise under a dark cloud. Meanwhile, Jonathan discovers the sheer power of a cowbell and refuses to let it go. It’s mystery, mayhem, and musical interludes—because nothing says true crime like an aggressively timed clank.

View photos

Join Ally as she guides you and the sexiest co-host on the planet, Jonathan, through one of Orange County’s most enduring mysteries: the sudden disappearance of college student Denise Huber on a summer night in 1991. Together, they’ll sift through the odd leads, the whispers of hidden evidence, and the puzzling turns that kept investigators—and a whole community—searching for answers for decades.

View episode photos

The case begins at 13:27 mark.

Ally gives Jonathan another chance at hosting an episode after the Friday the 13th episode debacle—but this time, he swears he’s done his homework. What starts as a seemingly ordinary family story quickly spirals into a maze of lies, a vanishing act, and a trail that leaves more questions than answers. This week, we dive into the baffling case of Chandler Halderson—where nothing is as it seems, and the truth is stranger than fiction.

View photos on Reddit

The case begins at the 10:30 mark.

Welcome back to Season 2! Ally and Jonathan kick things off with a chilling tale that'll keep you glued to your speakers—the infamous Chain of Rocks Bridge murders. When a peaceful night stroll turned deadly for the Kerry sisters, the entire Midwest held its breath. But what really happened that fateful night over the Mississippi River? Join us as we unravel the twists, turns, and shocking truths behind a case filled with controversy, betrayal, and a bridge that still whispers secrets. Buckle up, true-crime fans—it's about to get intriguing!

A quick errand to the store turned into a chilling final chapter—captured entirely on surveillance cameras. Hue unravels the haunting events of one ordinary trip gone tragically wrong.

View photos on Reddit

Hue and Jay unravel the bizarre and tragic tale of Amy Carlson's cult, Love Has Won, where spirituality took a dark and twisted turn. Join in on our conversation as we talk about one of our favorite true events of the last couple years.

View photos on Reddit

Diane seemed like a candidate for "Mom of the Year"—until her life took a shocking and tragic turn. Buckle up as Hue unravels the story that leaves Jay's jaw on the floor.