Episode 4 — The Guest List
In this episode, MaryAnna takes a deep dive into one of the central questions of the podcast: why is it acceptable to ask dead saints for help, but not your own grandmother?
It starts with a personal story — a visit to a local Orthodox church that left her speechless. The ancient aesthetic, the veneration of saints, the practice of intercession — asking the dead to advocate on your behalf — all of it fascinated her. But when mediumship came up, the same wall appeared that always appears.
From there, MaryAnna walks through the history of the Christian church: Pentecost as the starting gun, the five patriarchates that governed the early church together, and the Great Schism of 1054 that split Rome and Constantinople into two very different directions. The Filioque controversy — a single Latin word Rome added to the Nicene Creed without asking anyone — is unpacked as less of a theological disagreement and more of a power grab.
The episode then turns to the Bible itself. MaryAnna examines Deuteronomy 18, the passage most often used to condemn mediumship, and traces it back to its original context: the worship of Moloch and ritual human sacrifice — which has nothing to do with what modern mediums do. She breaks down the words necromancer, sorcerer, and diviner as they appear in both the Hebrew Bible and the Septuagint, and makes the case that "questioning the dead" through dark ritual is not the same thing as a medium sitting across from a grieving mother.
A key point: the word "medium" itself is a mistranslation that evolved over centuries. The original Hebrew terms were translated differently depending on the language, the era, and the translator — and scholars still debate what some of them actually meant.
The episode closes with a reminder that the wall between you and Spirit was built by people. Which means it was never real to begin with.
Topics covered:
- Saint intercession vs. mediumship — what's actually the difference?
- The Orthodox Church: history, structure, and surprising beliefs
- Pentecost and the five patriarchates
- The Great Schism of 1054 and the Filioque controversy
- Deuteronomy 18 in context — Moloch, human sacrifice, and mistranslation
- Necromancer vs. medium: the words are not the same
- The Septuagint and how Bible translation shapes theology
- The Desert Fathers and a non-Hollywood view of demons
Find Before Rome:Spotify | Apple Podcasts | beforerome.comNew episodes every Thursday