Episode Title: Unpacking Ben Sorer U'Moreh: Ancient Law, Modern Interpretations, and Miraculous Births Timestamp Breakdown:00:00 - 01:04: Announcements: Meir Reiser's 11th Birthday & Daf Yomi Achievement, West Rogers Park Shkia Times (June 9, 2026)01:04 - 02:44: Specific Shkia & Tzeis Hakochavim times according to different authorities (Rav Milamid, Chasam Sofer, Rabbeinu Tam); Today's Daf Yomi (Chullin, Rav Eli Stefansky).02:44 - 03:16: Brookfield Zoo Dinosaur Exhibit announcement.03:16 - 04:29: Recap of previous discussion: Gemara's role in refining character, Musar Seder, Chofetz Chaim on Yitzhar struggles and relevant Torah portions.04:29 - 05:20: The potential didactic purpose of Ben Sorer U'Moreh, even if it never occurred, as a "Tavlin" for specific struggles.05:20 - 06:22: Detailed review of the Ben Sorer U'Moreh halakha from the Torah: rebellious son, parental involvement, stoning.06:22 - 07:23: Rabbi Yehuda's opinion on the impossibility of Ben Sorer U'Moreh (equal parents), and Rav Yonasan/Yochanan's counter-claim (seeing one), with Rabbeinu Bachya's explanation.07:23 - 08:22: Discussing the authority of Amoraim arguing with Tannaim.08:22 - 09:20: When a Ben Sorer U'Moreh status begins: "two Sa'aros have grown" (Mishna).09:20 - 10:18: Explanation of "Sa'aros" in a clean lashon, and the specific wording of the pasuk regarding a "son."10:18 - 11:33: Meiri's reasoning for why only a son can be a Ben Sorer U'Moreh (his way to go after taiva), contrasted with the Yerushalmi's view that it's a "Gezerat HaKasuv" (no known reason).11:33 - 12:35: Further discussion on the Yerushalmi's view of Gezerat HaKasuv and the logical inconsistencies if not for it (e.g., a daughter's greater culpability, an older man's).12:35 - 13:39: How the Gezerat HaKasuv might support the idea that Ben Sorer U'Moreh never happened, learning from the structure of the halakha itself.13:39 - 14:26: Additional conditions for Ben Sorer U'Moreh (stealing only from father, not others), and contrasting with the Meiri's view again.14:26 - 15:54: Reconciling the Meiri and Yerushalmi on the male-only aspect of Ben Sorer U'Moreh.15:54 - 17:18: Tosafot's view on the Mishna's placement, and Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi's redaction of the Mishna regarding "Zaken" (referring to lower hair, not beard).17:18 - 18:00: The age range for Ben Sorer U'Moreh: from two Sa'aros until full "Zaken" (full beard growth).18:00 - 19:00: Derashot on "Ben" and "Ish" in the Ben Sorer U'Moreh pasuk, establishing the age (child, not man) and Chiyuv Mitzvot requirement.19:00 - 20:00: Gemara's question: "Ma Mekor She'ein Dam Ben Sorer U'Moreh Al Hakatan?" (Why no Ben Sorer U'Moreh for a minor?), considering the lack of Chiyuv Mitzvot.20:00 - 21:06: Chidushei HaRan's two-part question on punishing a Katan, even for fear, and the Sanhedrin Ketana's view.21:06 - 22:42: Addressing the second question of the Mishnah: why explicitly state a Katan is not a Ben Sorer U'Moreh if minors are never punished?22:42 - 24:31: Argument that since Ben Sorer U'Moreh is about future actions (squandering inheritance, stealing), a Katan could logically be included, so the Torah needed to exclude him.24:31 - 25:50: Rav Chissa in the name of Rav: "Ben" refers to someone close to the "Gevura of Ish" (manhood), not a young child.25:50 - 27:25: The "Ben" whose own "Ben" cannot be a Ben Sorer U'Moreh (i.e., a father who is himself a Katan). Discussion of Shlomo HaMelech and Dina's birth.27:25 - 28:33: The rarity of legitimate "servants" born to a Katan; the two Sa'aros requirement and "Zaken" (full hair) for a Ben Sorer U'Moreh.28:33 - 29:30: Rav Chissa's explanation of "Ish" in the pasuk referring to the father, not the Ben.29:30 - 31:09: Gemara's counter-arguments to Rav Yehuda's drasha on "Ish," and the implications of the pasuk's wording.31:09 - 32:34: Two drashot from one pasuk: "Ben" means a minor is exempt, and "Ben... Ish" means close to manhood.32:34 - 33:13: Rabba's view on "Katan ain o'moli" (a minor cannot give birth).33:13 - 34:56: The halakha of "Shivka Karuva" (close relatives) and Malkos (lashes), from a Briata.34:56 - 35:52: Gemara clarifies the situation: "Shalul ayata."35:52 - 36:12: Rav Kurutai: all Ben Sorer U'Moreh proceedings must occur within three months.36:12 - 37:27: Question: who would be a "nayad" (testify) about the two Sa'aros?37:27 - 38:11: Confirmation that the discussion of Ben Sorer U'Moreh is indeed related to Avshalom.38:11 - 38:53: Gemara's source for earlier generations giving birth at eight years old, from this week's Parasha.38:53 - 42:11: Deriving early fatherhood/grandfatherhood from the pasukim of Kalev, Uri, and Betzalel, calculating their ages and generations to show an 8-year generational gap.42:11 - 43:26: Mishna: Ben Sorer U'Moreh only applies if he eats meat and drinks wine, not other foods.43:26 - 43:40: The danger of sleeping on Torah (forgetting one's learning) and the need to end the class.20 Hashtags:#BenSorerUMoreh#DafYomi#JewishLaw#...
Mehr anzeigen
Weniger anzeigen
Jun 28 202622 Min.
Jun 11 202625 Min.
21 Min.
34 Min.
Jun 10 202644 Min.
1 Std. und 6 Min.
23 Min.