Manchester United are winning again… and suddenly the questions are louder than ever.

In this episode of A Semi-Informed Football Podcast, we dive into the unexpected resurgence under interim manager Michael Carrick following the departure of Ruben Amorim. Four straight wins had United fans dreaming again until West Ham halted the five-game fairytale. So now the real debate begins: is this a genuine tactical reset, or just the classic “new manager bounce”?

We break down Carrick’s tactical shift from Amorim’s rigid back three to a more natural back four system and why that subtle change may have unlocked Bruno Fernandes and stabilized the dressing room. We also ask the uncomfortable question: how many games does it actually take for a club like Manchester United to hand someone the permanent job?

Then we pivot to the bigger picture: managerial instability in modern football. Are clubs too quick to pull the trigger? Is the interim model becoming the safest business strategy in elite football?

And of course, we couldn’t avoid the VAR conversation. With fresh audits and renewed scrutiny around officiating standards, we examine whether VAR is improving accountability or just adding another layer of confusion to the modern game.

It’s tactics, boardroom politics, Premier League chaos, and just enough sarcasm to keep it semi-informed.

To contact us reach out to semiinformedfootball@gmail.com

Follow us on X at @SemiFooty

This week on A Semi-Informed Football Podcast, Marko welcomes Mark and Mateo back from the international break to talk about the state of modern coaching, sparked by fresh rumours around Diego Simeone and his future at Atlético Madrid.

After more than a decade in charge, Simeone has turned Atlético from a financial underdog into a European heavyweight ... yet even he isn’t immune to criticism, burnout, or whispers of retirement. So what does longevity actually buy you in today’s game?

The guys also debate:

Whether football still allows managers to fail and evolve

Simeone’s eye-watering salary compared to other elite coaches

Pep Guardiola and the feeling that an entire era may be ending

The Premier League’s obsession with instant success, using Michael Carrick’s short but explosive run as caretaker

Why some coaches build cultures, while others just survive cycles

It’s part tribute, part therapy session, and part crisis for managers everywhere...

To contact us reach out to semiinformedfootball@gmail.com

Follow us on X at @SemiFooty

After a brief hiatus, Semi-Informed Football returns with a solo episode diving into three Serie A matches that say far more about the season than the scorelines suggest.

Using Inter v Pisa, Roma v Milan, and Napoli v Juventus as case studies, this episode explores why modern Serie A is less about perfect tactics and more about adaptability, squad depth, pressure, and psychological resilience.

Who reacts when things go wrong? Who tightens up under the weight of a title chase? And who looks like a champion even on imperfect days?
A reset episode to kick off 2026 - with Mark and Matteo back soon, AND the arguments guaranteed to return.

To contact us reach out to semiinformedfootball@gmail.com

Follow us on X at @SemiFooty