While following a loose thread in Dylan Holt’s case, Mags and Amy stumble into a system that was never meant to be noticed.

As buried records surface and old names along with them, the line between past and present blurs. And just when it feels like they’ve found their footing, a call in the night pulls them toward a place no one crosses without consequence.

Send us a text

Support the show

As Mags and Amy dig into the past, old cases start rearranging themselves in real time. Assumptions they thought were settled begin to fracture, revealing a deeper pattern beneath Avalon Falls’ most familiar ghosts. What once felt like coincidence now looks deliberate. What once felt finished… clearly wasn’t.

Between unsettling discoveries, uncomfortable conversations, and a few questionable coping mechanisms, the girls are forced to confront a truth that’s been quietly rewriting itself for years.

Send us a text

Support the show

Mags and Amy return to Osprey Island — a place they swore they’d never see again — to find that the past hasn’t been waiting quietly.

The island holds answers, but not the kind anyone was hoping for — and not in the shape anyone remembers. The girls are forced to confront a familiar realization: sometimes the most dangerous thing isn’t what you uncover — it’s what changes once you do.

Send us a text

Support the show

When a familiar nemesis returns with an impossible request, Mags and Amy find themselves pulled into a search that hits uncomfortably close to home. As a missing girl, an anxious mother, and a trail of half-answers collide, the girls follow a shadowy trail of clues — and realize how quickly curiosity can turn into something much darker.

Old rivalries resurface, new alliances form under pressure, and every step forward raises more questions than it answers.

Send us a text

Support the show

After a violent warning forces them back onto the road, Mags and Amy follow the clues into one of the county’s quietest institutions — and uncover a trail of missing records, buried names, and secrets that were never meant to be found. As the past presses closer, the girls begin to realize Dylan wasn’t just uncovering old stories… he was tracing a pattern that’s still very much alive.

Send us a text

Support the show

After uncovering the web of secrets Dylan Holt left behind, Mags and Amy follow his trail beyond Avalon Falls and into the quiet edges of Cedarbrook, where nothing is ever as ordinary as it looks. Each clue pulls them deeper into the truth Dylan was chasing -- and deeper into the history the town has tried to bury. Old stories resurface, new connections spark, and the girls find themselves caught between the past they survived and the one that’s finally catching up to them.

Send us a text

Support the show

After watching a message Dylan Holt recorded before his death, Mags and Amy follow his final clue deep into the woods outside the town. The journey stirs up buried memories and unresolved tension as they come face-to-face with the ghosts of their past — and uncover something that refuses to stay forgotten.

Send us a text

Support the show

After a day of break-ins, bad cops, and buried truths, Mags and Amy finally start to feel like partners again -- just in time for everything to get stranger. Because in Avalon Falls, the closer you get to answers, the louder the ghosts start talking.

Send us a text

Support the show