In 2008, five women were murdered inside a Tinley Park store. One woman survived. A 911 call was made. DNA evidence existed.

Eighteen years later, no one has been arrested.

This episode of Fractured Justice examines the timeline, the forensic evidence, and the unanswered questions that refuse to go away.

Support the show

Support the show for as little as $1 or sign up for premium content.

A pregnant young woman vanished overnight.

No footprints.
No goodbye.
Only stories that didn’t match the data.

In this episode of Fractured Justice: True Crime, we examine a Michigan case where missed warning signs, late-night phone calls, conflicting family timelines, and disturbing digital evidence told a story authorities failed to stop.

This was not sudden.
It was preventable.

We break down how control, family violence, untreated mental health issues, and rural isolation collided — and how underfunded systems left a vulnerable pregnant woman with nowhere to go.

This isn’t speculation.
It’s evidence, timelines, and uncomfortable truths.

New episodes every Tuesday

Support the show

They told her family one word: hypothermia.

But a label isn’t an explanation.

Episode 1 of Fractured Justice: True Crime examines a winter disappearance that refuses to settle into a simple ending. A night out. Dangerous Code Blue cold. A woman vanishes. Less than twenty-four hours later, she is found under an Interstate 95 overpass—more than a mile from where the night began.

This episode is built the way real investigations work:
• What we can verify
• Where the gaps are
• What investigators typically check next
• And the one question that matters most

We walk through the environment without inventing a route, test the possible paths using a logic-tree framework, and examine why winter exposure cases so often collapse into silence before the full story is understood.

This is not conspiracy theater.
This is not internet certainty.
This is a careful, pressure-tested approach to unanswered questions.

The question that won’t let go—and the one her family keeps asking—is simple:

How did she get there?

Follow the show and download the episode to keep this investigation alive.
Episode 2 goes deeper into the winter-vanishing pattern and the systems that decide when a case stays open—or quietly closes.

CHAPTERS — FRACTURED JUSTICE: TRUE CRIME
Episode 1: Frozen Secrets – The Deadly Winter Vanishings of 2026
00:00 — The Case & the Cold: Introduction to the disappearance of Micaiah Matthews and why cold exposure cases demand a different kind of investigation.

00:30 — The Last Night: What’s known about the nightclub, the moments before she vanished, and why winter nights distort timelines.

02:54 — Distance, Shelter, and the Winter Trap: Why “a mile” in freezing conditions isn’t just distance, how overpasses factor into winter deaths, and the environmental risks people underestimate.

04:26 — Injuries, Gaps, and Unanswered Questions: The bruises, the location, missing surveillance, and why early labels don’t always explain the full story.

07:58 — Decision Funnels & Human Assumptions: How alcohol, cold, and short gaps create dangerous decision funnels—and how friends, bystanders, and systems assume safety too quickly.

10:08 — Inside the Investigation: How investigators typically trace movement, establish control points, and work through incomplete data in cold-weather cases.

14:24 — The Silence That Follows: What it means when timelines go quiet, how trauma and exposure complicate cause and effect, and why unanswered miles matter.

17:58 — Patterns, Prevention, and Responsibility: Comparing similar winter cases, what recurring patterns reveal, and how small decisions, community vigilance, and systemic responsibility can save lives.

Support the show