Prompted by an email from listener Kenton, we revisit the paper-versus-plastic debate. While plastic pollution is a serious problem, we argue that the best choice depends on the product and propose three tests for "good" plastic packaging: it should be recyclable, contain at least 50% recycled content, and be significantly lighter than the alternative. Using these criteria, plastic wrap around recycled toilet roll may outperform paper wrapping, while also creating demand for recycled plastic that might otherwise be incinerated.

This episode of Recycled Content, is the 'Rubbish Question' from episode 71 of Talking Rubbish, which first aired on 4th December 2025.

While every effort has been made to provide the most accurate information, recycling guidance changes quickly and some advice may become outdated over time. Always check with your local council for the rules that apply to recycling in your area. On the main Talking Rubbish podcast, we include an additions and corrections section where we update anything we may have got wrong.

These clips come from the weekly show, Talking Rubbish - The Recycling Podcast

We would love you to join our community on Discord

Special thanks to our sponsor, Ecosurety

To get exclusive videos and clips, follow us on Instagram, TikTok, X, Threads or Facebook; @rubbishpodcast or YouTube: @talkingrubbishpodcast

Or you can contact James and Robbie with questions or just general rubbish musings using the email address talkingrubbishpodcast@gmail.com or by texting them via WhatsApp on 07356 069 232

Music licence ID: 3GXXBILNPGLYRUZF