The Superhero Show Goes Off-Script: Hunting for the Best Album of 2025

This week on The Superhero Show, the hosts hit pause on Cadillacs and Dinosaurs and dive headfirst into a brand-new challenge: crowning the Best Album of 2025. Known across the network for breaking down films on Movie of the Year, the team admits that music requires a different kind of expertise. So, instead of avoiding the challenge, they bring the “Best Of” format directly into The Superhero Show and let the debate rip.

To tackle the massive question of the Best Album of 2025, the hosts build a full tournament-style bracket. The lineup pulls from critics’ lists and major media outlets, creating a field packed with the year’s most talked-about releases. Each matchup sparks lively discussion as the hosts weigh artistry, cultural impact, replay value, and pure vibes.

Albums going head-to-head include Lux by Rosalía, Getting Killed by Geese by Geese, Debí Tirar Más Fotos by Bad Bunny, Choke Enough by Oklou, Let God Sort Em Out by Clipse, Mayhem by Lady Gaga, Viagr Aboys by Viagra Boys, and Ego Death at a Bachelorette Party by Hayley Williams. With every round, the bracket tightens and the debates get louder.

In addition to the critical darlings, each host brings their personal favorite album of the year into the bracket. These wild-card picks test whether passion can overpower consensus. Some personal choices surprise the panel by holding their own against heavyweight contenders, while others spark heated disagreements over taste, expectations, and what truly defines the Best Album of 2025.

As the bracket narrows, the conversations shift from casual opinions to full-on arguments. The hosts debate genre boundaries, longevity, and which albums will define 2025 years from now. Unexpected upsets shake the bracket, and longtime favorites face serious challenges before a single album ultimately claims the title.

By the end of the episode, the hosts reach a hard-fought consensus on the Best Album of 2025, closing out a special episode that blends their signature energy with a fresh musical focus. Whether you agree with the final pick or not, this episode proves that The Superhero Show can tackle any pop culture battlefield—even one filled with beats instead of capes.

Want more "Best of 2025" episodes? Check out Movie of the Year podcast!

Missed any of the past best of 2025 episodes? Catch up here!

Want to watch along with us? Of course you do! Here's a link to all the episodes!