épisodes

  • 233 William Cecil Saves the World
    18 Nov 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    We go into the consequential repeal of Edwardian Usury prohibitions.

    We take a detailed look at the usury debates of the time, quite fascinating, and we can see Cecil thinking his way through the problem using a method of analysis he had learned as a young man at Cambridge.

    We look at the thought processes involved, not just from Cecil and those close to him, Thomas Smith and Throckmorton, but of the philosophical and political thought of the time which was much more personal and concerned with sin than the abstract analysis we tend to perform today.

    We answer the question, was William Cecil really Superman?

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    34 min
  • 232 A Deeper Look at Elizabethan Policy Part 2
    11 Nov 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    We cover policy contributions from Thomas Starkey to Thomas Smith to Francis Bacon. The main policy discussions are about the Poor Laws, the Recoinage and Labor policy.

    Then we go into the ideological support for the poor laws. There are three bible passages that had a great effect on Tudor ideas about the poor laws. They are in conflict, at one level. It was the resolution of the conflict that made the English Poor Laws so successful. This discussion explains whey the parish elders, the vestrymen, behaved the way they did in the operation of the poor laws, which was left a bit mysterious in the prior episodes.

    The biggest policy change, allowing for loans at interest up to 10%, is reserved for episode 233.

    One of the biggest issues in understanding policy is that the way the policies were carried out on the ground is very different from the letter of the legislation. That's a lot of it.

    There is discussion about the influence of Richard Perkins.

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    33 min
  • 231 A Closer look at Elizabethan Policy; Utopia vs Empiricism
    4 Nov 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    We compare the Humanist vs Lutheran vs Elizabethan poverty policies in some depth.

    Part of that involves a deeper analysis of More's Utopia, as well as related work by Erasmus and Juan De Vives. Erasmus and More's 1515 work was foundational to later Humanist poverty policy and also accounts for the similarity between the early Humanist policy and the early Lutheran policy as well as Cromwell's 1531 beginning.

    Some time is spent comparing Wycliff and Lollardy with the Devotio Moderna, as these were origin ideologies for the Netherlands and England, which very quickly became the leaders of the world in per capita income terms. England also had Piers Ploughman by Langland, around the same time as Wycliff, so they got a double dose of the message that elites needed to become less terrible, corrupt and doomed to hell.

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    32 min
  • 230. Did the Poor Laws Make England Rich?
    28 Oct 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    The question seems crazy and yet there are entangled facts that we need to consider. This is a 16th and 17th century issue.

    1. The obsession over employment for the poor.

    2. The actions of Common Law operating over many decades.

    3. The near dictatorial power of JPs in certain kinds of land use disputes.

    This ended with a set of property laws that allowed property owners unusually free use of their own land for business purposes, which was not the case before, is not the case now, and has seldom in the world ever been the case. It used to be easy for other powerful people to veto an owner's use of land, then for a time it was not. That had consequences.

    The episode also has a great deal of detail on the Poor Laws and their development from the 17th to the 18th century. As with all complex arrangements, the unintended consequences tend to be the most powerful.

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    33 min
  • 229 The English Poor Laws
    21 Oct 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    Poverty policy was deeply entangled with other obsessions of the 16th and 17th century England. Combine these obsessions with the local dictatorial power of the JPs and the concept of Common Law, and you get a surprising result.

    There were many false starts in the European efforts to fight poverty in the early 16th century. Traditionalists, Protestants and Humanists all took quite similar steps towards fighting poverty.

    They all made similar mistakes, putting the agency and control over money, at the wrong level of poverty fighting machinery. England took a different approach, from all of these.

    We have talked a lot about these differences, experiment, fail, try again. Learn from the parish over there.

    But all that effort over the poor resulted in substantial taxation. 20% of all land taxes went towards helping the poor. One obsession for the JPs (can we say as a consequence?) was the employment of the poor. Combine that with common law, Joan Thirsk style economic projects, and businesses are allowed to go forward with projects that would create employment that before would have been vetoed by other interested parties.

    Things changed, culture changed, law changed.

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    34 min
  • 228. The Dangerous Poor; Poverty in Tudor and Stuart England
    14 Oct 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    Great context on English society and the Poor Law mechanism.

    “According to the 16th century stereotype, the undeserving pauper was typically rootless, masterless and homeless. A Vagrant. His behavior was disorderly and criminal, that of a rogue.”

    In the 16th century, the poor laws and other laws make the vagrant criminal. But, like other laws, there is a massive amount of local discretion when it comes to enforcement. There were basically so many people who you might call a vagrant, that local officials just did not punish all pauper wanderers. And there were people who, if they were guilty of some other crime would be punished for that, as for example they were a thief, a magistrate might ignore that they were also a vagrant.

    It was only a small minority of immigrants who were ever punished as vagrants. Usually, if they got work or rented a place to live, the authorities would look the other way. They didn’t have to, but they could.

    We look at the dangerous poor, their punishments, movements and the attitudes of the respectable towards them. They were really the greatest source of crime, and many lived highly dysfunctional lives.

    There were definitely professional beggars as well. “Counterfeit bedlams, and a counterfeit cripple in Herefordshire, one of Salisbury’s vagrants was a Dumberer pretending he hath no tongue.”

    There is an abuse of power story told too. The power of overseers to regulate the family life of the poor is not a well known story.

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    35 min
  • 227. Tudor Poor Laws and Approach to Poverty
    7 Oct 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    Europe wide, there were Humanist driven policy responses to poverty in the 16th century, which we have covered in some detail. These were essentially all failures.

    There was one successful poverty program which, despite many flaws, solved the problem of famine among the poor. Just one? How could this possibly be?

    If we brutally summarize Proust we would say, first of all, most areas did not rationalize their agricultural production. They had too many inefficient small holdings, and/or they established price controls which lowered production or distorted production. Inefficient small holdings come from cultural preference, and is usually reinforced by legal and bureaucratic institutions, often based on little more than dumb preference.

    Second, in the brutal summarization, price controls distorting production, is a simple corruption by elites, who tend to be terrible. Terrible in the way I usually refer to as being against human flourishing. There is even a weak version of this in England relating to the corn laws.

    Third, is the use of high status people to use the money, in the context of a seriously hierarchical society where the high status people cannot be questioned or audited as they were in England in the Bording Administrative History episodes. In other words, scummy elites who are corrupt.

    A poorly structured economy, and terrible elites is just the human normal, which is everywhere all the time, and these things tend to work against the poverty programs run all over Europe. Another problem was simple inefficiency, a wasting of resources used to fight poverty. The flow of money they were able to raise to help the poor was inadequate, partially because the vast majority of the money was spent on administration. Examples we had was that the monastery at St Deny only gave 3% of the revenue they raised directly to the poor in the form of food, clothing or money.

    St Deny is not considered a great outlier, but institutions spending 90% on their own people and priorities, are common through history, right down to today. Efforts start with prestige and high status people working on solving a problem, but generally devolve into corrupt people doing what they want. That’s just how institutions work.

    When so much is wasted, there is just not enough money.

    And yet, there was a successful poverty program, that also was born with Humanist roots, but evolved and changed into a more 'empirical' and less 'critical' approach, that actually solved the problem of famine for the poor.

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    31 min
  • 226. Luther, Erasmus and the Poor
    30 Sep 2026

    You can send a text, include contact info to get a response.

    During the 16th century, this whole social controversy over the treatment of the poor ranged across and intersected with the Reformation. You also have the social changes happening where the power of the central court is growing and that of the knights is weakening. The economy is becoming more dependent on cash and trade and division of labor. Wealth is increasing, but at the same time there are more people and almost all the new people, meaning the marginal growth in numbers, are extremely poor.

    Intellectually, the Humanists are dominant. They lead the policy reforms towards the poor, as a result, the initial policies of all involved are quite similar.

    The European climate is cooling, There is a radical challenge to the single greatest institution or corporate body on the continent. Not only is the church being splintered, and challenged at every ideological level, but the church engages in a great council and comes out of it quite changed. Superficially the same, but more fixed in doctrine, less able to change doctrine as scientific advances happen. The counter reformation places the church against science in a way that it was not before.

    All this is happening in societies that are not particularly used to rapid change.

    We finish with Spain's national effort at treatment of the poor.

    afficher plus Afficher moins
    29 min