Is it ethical to bill a client a human rate for work your AI tool finished in a fraction of the time?
In this episode of the Alpha Lawyer Podcast, host Jason Marsh sits down with Colin Levy, general counsel, adjunct professor at Albany Law School, and author of the new book Code Switched: A Lawyer’s Guide to the Era of AI, to talk about where law firms are getting AI wrong, how to buy and roll out AI tools without getting burned, and what it all means for client expectations, pricing, and law firm economics. Colin serves on the board of directors of CLOC (the Corporate Legal Operations Consortium), was named a Fastcase 50 honoree, and has worked across law firms, in-house legal departments, and legal technology.
Rather than treating AI as either a cure-all or a threat, Colin argues law firms are making two opposite mistakes: waiting it out and hoping nothing changes, or buying every new tool without defining the problem first. He makes the case that charging a human rate for work AI did in a fraction of the time isn’t just a pricing question, it’s an ethics question.
🎧 Listen to learn: ✔️ The two opposite mistakes law firms make with AI: waiting it out, or buying every tool without a defined problem ✔️ Why “start with the problem, not the technology” should guide every AI purchase decision ✔️ What AI is actually good at today (pattern recognition, document review, routine drafting) versus where it still breaks down (novel legal questions, emotionally complex client situations) ✔️ Why AI hallucinations are a feature of how these tools work, not a bug, and why that puts the burden of verification back on the lawyer ✔️ What to actually negotiate in an AI vendor contract: data use, training rights, storage, liability for outputs, and pricing structure ✔️ Why Colin says buying the tool is the easy part, and successful AI adoption is really a change management problem ✔️ Why Colin believes charging a human rate for work AI completed in a fraction of the time isn’t justifiable, and may be unethical ✔️ Whether the billable hour can survive AI driven productivity gains, and what pricing models are emerging alongside it ✔️ Why client conversations now need to address AI use upfront, including what clients will and won’t allow it to be used for ✔️ What becomes more valuable about lawyers themselves as AI takes over more of the routine work: judgment, discernment, and relationship building
📄 Episode page with transcript, chapters, and show notes: https://www.alphalawyer.io/human-rates-for-machine-work-how-ai-is-changing-legal-work-and-law-firm-economics/
🔗 Follow and Connect with Colin Levy 🌍 Website: https://www.colinslevy.com/ 💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colinslevy/ 🐦 X (Twitter): https://x.com/c_levy_law
📚 Get the book: Code Switched, A Lawyer’s Guide to the Era of AI, on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0H6R2W585
🔗 Follow and Connect with Host, Jason Marsh 🌍 Website: https://www.alphalawyer.io/ 💼 LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/marshjason/ 📺 YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@GoAlphaLawyer