Send us Fan Mail

Episode Title: The Slap and the Sideline — Patton, The Incidents in Sicily, and The General Who Was Worth More Benched Than Commanding

Season 3, Episode 6 — The Decisions That Shaped the Western War

On the afternoon of August 3rd, 1943, Lieutenant General George S. Patton walked through the wards of the 15th Evacuation Hospital near Nicosia in Sicily.

He came to Private Charles H. Kuhl of Mishawaka, Indiana. Kuhl was sitting on a supply crate and showed no visible wound. Patton asked what was wrong with him. Kuhl said he guessed he could not take it. Patton struck him across the face and ordered him removed from the hospital.

Seven days later, at the 93rd Evacuation Hospital, Patton encountered Private Paul G. Bennett. Bennett was twenty-one years old. He had been in continuous combat for four years. He was shaking. Patton drew his pistol, held it to Bennett's head, and called him a coward.

The hospital commanders filed reports. Eisenhower received them within days. He wrote Patton a private letter — one of the most measured and devastating documents of the entire war — telling him that the incidents were indefensible and that he had no choice but to suppress the story, force Patton to apologize to every man in his command, and remove him from a combat role.

When Patton wrote in his diary about the apology tour that followed, he described it as being forced to soft-soap a skulker.

On November 21st 1943, broadcaster Drew Pearson went on national radio and told America what had happened in those two hospital tents. The public outrage was immediate and enormous. Congress debated whether Patton should be dismissed entirely.

He was not. Because German military intelligence had assessed Patton as the most dangerous Allied commander, and wherever he was positioned, they believed, was where the real blow would fall. A disgraced, sidelined Patton — visibly removed from command — was one of the most valuable deception assets the Allies possessed.

Operation Fortitude placed him in command of a phantom army pointed at Pas-de-Calais. The Germans believed it. Even after D-Day, Hitler held his Panzer reserves at the wrong coast for critical weeks because he was waiting for Patton's real attack.

The most effective American field commander of the war was worth more to the Allied cause benched than most generals were commanding. His genius and his worst impulse were, in the end, inseparable.

In this episode Amanda and Harry examine the full Patton — the incidents, the apology tour, the deception, the Third Army, Bastogne, and what the honest assessment of a man this complicated actually requires.

Send your thoughts and story ideas to BestStoryPublishing@gmail.com

Visit us at www.beststorypublishing.com